Something like this probably happens in most of our homes. Your child plays happily on their own for twenty minutes while you make dinner. Nobody says a word. Then, a cup of water hits the floor, and you’re across the kitchen in two seconds, surprised, quick to clean up, and asking what happened.
From your child’s perspective, those two behaviors worked very differently for them. Playing quietly got nothing. The spilled cup got everything.
Kids repeat what gets noticed. Attention is one of the most powerful things in a child’s day (especially mom’s or dad’s), and here’s the part that surprises a lot of parents: it doesn’t have to be warm and positive to count. A sigh, a “please stop that,” even a long look can all land as being seen. For a child who wants connection, a frustrated reaction can still feel like a better deal than being ignored. Behavior analysts call this process positive reinforcement, and in this case it’s attention that is reinforcing the behavior. As a result, a behavior that earns attention becomes more likely to show up again, especially when their attention bucket is running low.
The good news is that your attention can work to your benefit. The same pull that can strengthen the behaviors we’re trying to see less of (whining, interrupting, or throwing food) can strengthen the ones we want more of (cooperation, playing on their own, or waiting).
Here are some clues that attention might be in the mix
Pay attention to whether your child:
- does the behavior, then glances around to see who noticed
- does it more when you’re on the phone, cooking, or talking to someone else (times when your attention is on something else)
- repeats it right after getting a reaction, even a frustrated one
- stops when no one’s around
- gets bigger or louder if you turn away
These are clues, not proof. The same behavior can happen for very different reasons, and the same child can do the same behavior for different reasons on different days. That’s what makes it tricky, and why it’s worth being curious rather than certain.
A few ways to use this
Notice the good, out loud and specifically. Quiet, ordinary good moments are the easiest to miss, and they matter most. “You kept building even when the tower fell” tells your child exactly what you liked.
Keep your response to minor, harmless behavior short and calm. The goal is for the everyday annoyances not to be the most exciting moment of your child’s day. Of course, anything unsafe always gets a response.
Fill the tank before it runs low. A few minutes of your full attention, phone down, makes it less necessary for your child to go looking for your attention the hard way. In one study of elementary-school children with a range of disabilities, whose problem behavior had been earning adult attention, ten minutes of attention up front led to less of that behavior than ten minutes of being ignored.
One honest heads-up
When you start reacting less to something that used to get a big reaction, the behavior can briefly get louder or bigger before it settles. That can happen, and it doesn’t mean your new approach isn’t working. In a review of 113 sets of clinical data, researchers saw a temporary surge like this in about one in four, and less often when other strategies were used alongside. This spike in behavior also tends to be the point where parents most want company in the process.
Small shifts count
You won’t catch every good moment. You’ll still react to the spilled cup sometimes, because you’re a person and it’s a large puddle of water all over your kitchen floor. Small shifts add up, and you don’t have to get it perfect every time to make a difference.
If you’re ever unsure what a particular behavior is getting your child, that’s a great thing to untangle with someone who can look at your family’s specific situation.
Curious how to tell what a behavior is really after? Why It Keeps Happening is a good next read.
Ashley Weber is a board certified behavior analyst (BCBA-D) and the founder of Phase Family Coaching, where she helps Bay Area families navigate childhood behavior with practical, evidence-based parent coaching.